We may receive a commission when you use our affiliate links. However, this does not impact our recommendations.
Tube Extractors are the Best Option
Sawtooth edges make these small tools very handy to have around the shop. Use a drill press, if possible, to bore a clean hole around the screw. Or, a hand-held drill with a guide block works fine for screws located outside of the reach of a drill press. Once the screw is out, patch the hole with a length of dowel or a matching plug.
– For screw sizes #4 – #8, use a 1/4″ tube
– For screw sizes #4 – #10, use a 5/16″ tube
– For screw sizes #10 – #12, use a 3/8″ tube
Removing Broken Screws with Pliers
– If the screw shank is fully above the surface, simply grab the shank with needle-nose pliers
and twist the broken screw out.
– If the area won’t be visible when finished or the shank is flush with the surface, excavate around the shank, then use pliers to extract the screw.
– Stubborn screws may loosen with heat applied directly to the screw with a soldering iron.
Rotary Tool to the Rescue
Use a cut-off wheel on a rotary tool to cut a slot into the top of the broken screw. Then, use a slot-head screwdriver to reverse the screw’s shaft out of the hole.
Tips to Avoid Breaking Screws
– Use a better quality screw.
– Drill properly sized pilot holes, which are different for hardwood and softwood (see chart at below).
– Lubricate the screw with wax or paraffin. Grease or oil may leach into the wood causing finish problems.
– Always clamp the workpiece to your bench or in a vise to hold the piece securely.
– For brass screws, first install a steel screw of equal size to thread the hole, then replace that screw with the brass screw.
Proper Sizes for Pilot Holes
– Tom Nunlist; Illustrations by Matt Bantly
Here are some supplies and tools we find essential in our everyday work around the shop. We may receive a commission from sales referred by our links; however, we have carefully selected these products for their usefulness and quality.
